1.0 KiB
First Pass
Category: This paper is an experimental paper.
Context: The context of this paper is using a couple different techniques synthesize control programs using different formal methods tools.
Correctness: I trust Max's integrity. Some of the citations were funky and the intro was fluffy though.
Contributions: This paper shows that using LTL and other formal methods still struggles to generate controllers for significantly challenging systems. The high bay warehouse used to create this paper had to be simplified. Then, they introduce an SMT solver based method to try to generate code.
Clarity: The intro and conclusion do not provide very strong clarity on what they actually did other than "high assurance is high difficulty", and that we're not really there yet on HACPS.
Second Pass
What is the main thrust?
What is the supporting evidence?
What are the key findings?
Third Pass
Recreation Notes:
Hidden Findings:
Weak Points? Strong Points?