% The Paradox
\begin{frame}{Nuclear control faces a fundamental tension}

  \begin{center}
    \begin{tikzpicture}
      \draw[thick, fill=gray!20] (0,0) rectangle (12,7);
      \node[align=center, text width=10cm] at (6,3.5) {
        \textbf{FIGURE: The Human Paradox}\\[0.3cm]
        Split diagram:\\[0.2cm]
        LEFT side (green): Why we need humans\\
        (judgment, flexibility, novel situations)\\[0.2cm]
        RIGHT side (red): Why humans fail\\
        (7±2 memory, seconds vs ms, biases, stress)\\[0.3cm]
        Bottom: Current division of labor\\
        Automated = Terminal ops | Manual = Routine ops\\[0.2cm]
        Arrow pointing to gap: \textbf{This is backwards!}
      };
    \end{tikzpicture}
  \end{center}

  %SPEAKER NOTES: See comments below
%
    \textbf{The Paradox:} Human operators are both essential for flexibility and the primary source of failure

    \textbf{Why We Need Humans:}
    Strategic decision-making, procedure interpretation, handling novel situations, adaptive judgment, legal authority (10 CFR 55)

    \textbf{Why Humans Fail:}
    Working memory: 7±2 items, response time: seconds vs milliseconds, cognitive biases (confirmation, anchoring), stress degrades performance 10-50x, error rates: 0.001 → 1.0 under accident conditions

    \textbf{Current Division:}
    Automated = Emergency protection (trip systems, ECCS) --- terminal operations;
    Manual = Strategic operations (startup, mode transitions, power changes) --- routine operations

    \textbf{Goal:} Reliability of automation with sophistication of human decision-making
% (End of speaker notes)
\end{frame}
